IMF Annual Meeting 2026 Nordic-Baltic CSO Letter
Dear Mr. Degn
We, the Nordic-Baltic civil society constituency working for human rights, the eradication of poverty, climate justice as well as fair distribution of power and resources, thank you for the opportunity to comment on the Nordic-Baltic Constituency’s work within the IMF. We would like to take the opportunity to raise some issues of concern ahead of the 2026 Annual Meetings.
Review of the Low-Income Debt Sustainability Framework (LIC-DSF)
We raised the LIC-DSF review in earlier letters, and have shared suggestions for how LIC-DSF better can support governments in assuming their responsibility to maintain and expand social protection and other social spending (See input from Global Coalition for Social Protection Floors here). In July, after having seen the proposed changes to the LIC-DSF, we provided specific comments through the Public Consultation (See input here). Key comments:
● Excessive fiscal consolidation, resulting in e.g. that governments fail to pay teachers and health workers' salaries, should be seen as an indicator of unsustainable debt.
● Fiscal multipliers are crucial, the choice of multiplier must be fully transparent and specific in each analysis (bearing in mind that fiscal multipliers of investments in social protection tend to be higher than multipliers of total government expenditures)
● We welcome the long-term modules, and encourage further work on the development module, including fiscal multipliers.
Question: To what extent are the concerns we have raised reflected in the Nordic-Baltic position on the LIC-DSF review process?
Review of Program design and conditionality (RoC)
For many years, the main public criticism of the IMF has been motivated by IMF policy conditions. As the IMF itself has recognised, too often, its policy condition has prompted excessive fiscal consolidation/austerity measures that have serious social effects as well as negative impact on long term growth. Although we have seen a clear change in IMF at global policy level, evidence show that IMF’s policy conditions continue to be deeply problematic:
● A recent analysis of 21 peer-reviewed academic studies as well as the IMF’s own research show that IMF programs are associated with increased poverty, inequality, neonatal mortality and deforestation (Hirschel-Burns and Zucker-Marques, 2026, “Toward More Effective IMF Programs”).
● Although IMF has acknowledged the need for counter-cyclical financial policies in crisis situations, IMF policy advice and conditionality for low- and middle-income countries remain largely pro-cyclical, with a continued emphasis on fiscal consolidation. A recent study found that of the 100 Article IV reports analysed in the study, none presented counter-cyclical policy recommendations that respond to increasing social inequalities (Bretton Woods Project, 2025, Brace for Impact: Social and gender inequalities in IMF surveillance).
● In relation to social protection, the same study found that 95% of the Article IV reports recommended removing universal social protection measures, such as consumer subsidies and pensions, and replacing them with targeted social protection to ‘protect the most vulnerable’ or finding ways to ‘better target’ social protection programmes to contain public spending.
Given the current disconnect between IMF high level policies and those implemented at country level, the Review of Conditionalities is of utmost importance.
Act Church of Sweden contributed to the online consultation (see input here) and participated in an online session in June where IMF staff reported back, in a general manner, on the views that had been submitted. In general, CSO’s main concerns relate to the social and distributional costs of fiscal adjustments, as well as climate-related impact. The following message from the Independent Evaluation Office (IEO) was highlighted: "Other priority areas include (...) better assessing the distributional effects of fiscal measures and their feedback loops to the sustainability and credibility of future fiscal adjustments."
Despite the consistent calls for greater attention to the social impact of austerity measures, the IMF seems to be going in the other direction. We have received information that the IMF Board on its meeting on 14th of September would adopt a policy that will require frontloaded fiscal adjustment in future loan programs, meaning that they will require the bulk of austerity cuts from countries at the beginning of the program rather than implementing them gradually throughout. Some of the signatories of this letter have also signed an international letter sent to IMF EDs on September 11 (CSO Letter to the IMF Board on RoC).
Question: What priorities has the constituency had in the RoC process, and what can you say about the outcome? What is your response to the letter signed by 130+ organisations?
Ebola crisis in (DRC): urgent need to increase the CCRT
As the Ebola crisis continues to grow in DRC, the country should focus maximum resources on managing the epidemic and expanding its health system. Being a heavily indebted country, however, it lacks the necessary resources and is obliged to prioritise debt servicing. The Catastrophe Containment and Relief Trust (CCRT) is a dedicated mechanism allowing the poorest countries to redirect fiscal resources from debt repayment to protecting lives in crisis situations. The CCRT is however severely underfunded, its available resources total only $120 million, whereas the DRC alone must pay the IMF almost $300 million in debt service in 2027.
This means that every time a major health crisis erupts, the IMF must ask its shareholders to replenish an instrument specifically designed to respond to recurring shocks, causing political delays in delivering what should be an automatic, rapid stabilizer.
Marina Zucker-Marquez, a debt expert from Boston University who met with the Central Bank, Ministry of Finance and Ministry of Foreign Affairs in Stockholm in June 2026, has proposed that the IMF sell a small fraction of its gold reserve to finance the CCRT permanently (Ebola is Back-and the IMF’s Relief Fund Is Empty by Marina Zucker-Marques - Project Syndicate). This would be a similar but a much smaller action than when gold reserves were sold in 1999 and 2009. According to this proposal, The IMF need to act both in the short and medium term:
● DRC should receive relief from upcoming IMF payments, giving it fiscal space to focus its efforts where they matter most: combating the epidemic and expanding the social safety net.
● An immediate donor-replenishment campaign should be initiated to replenish the CCRT.
● In parallel, serious negotiations on a gold endowment should begin to render the question of CCRT funding permanently moot.
Question: Do you agree that the CCRT requires sustainable financing in order to function as a rapid stabilizer in times of crisis? What is your view on the proposal to use gold reserves for this purpose, both in principle and in light of current IMF member positions?
Review of the G20 Common Framework
The international debt architecture has proven ineffective, and several countries now spend more on servicing public debt than they do on health and education. This undermines other efforts to expand governments’ fiscal space to invest in development. In the Common African Position on Debt, African leaders themselves point out that support for debt restructuring can come with demands for reforms and budget cuts that undermine national development strategies. They also highlight how economic instability hampers job creation, while rising debt-servicing costs divert resources away from investments in education and employment.
A new report by Save the Children UK and Debt Justice UK sets out six proposals for improving the Common Framework. These measures, together with efforts to increase developing countries’ access to capital, could provide new financing for development in countries that currently have to prioritise debt repayments over essential public services.
The recommendations are:
● More and better debt relief to enable countries to invest in development.
● A temporary suspension of debt payments during restructuring negotiations.
● A mechanism to ensure that restructurings are binding on all creditors.
● A clear definition of comparability of treatment among creditors.
● A faster restructuring process. This would require stronger commitments from bilateral creditors while also putting pressure on private creditors.
● Greater transparency around debt data.
Debt restructurings must result in debt levels that are low enough to keep the risk of default at a moderate level and provide sufficient fiscal space to absorb shocks. In other words, countries must be able to cope with unforeseen events after restructuring their debt. This would also create greater scope for investment in development.
The Nordic-Baltic constituency should clearly support the Supplement to the 2018 Guidance Note on the Bank-Fund Debt Sustainability Framework for Low-Income Countries, which states that “restoring debt sustainability entails reducing the risk rating to at least a moderate risk of external debt distress”.
The same guidance note states that, “depending on a country’s vulnerability to future shocks, a restructuring process may need to aim to leave ‘some space’ or ‘substantial space’ to absorb shocks. This limits the risk of countries returning to high risk.”
This guidance is not currently being followed, and both Chad and Zambia have been categorised as being at high risk following debt restructuring. If the guidance were followed, however, it would establish an important precedent whereby restructuring should result in a moderate risk assessment, with substantial space to absorb potential shocks. This would minimise the risk of repeated restructurings and bring debt repayments and interest payments down to genuinely sustainable levels.
The report Now is the Time to Act, p. 11, provides further details on how more and better debt relief could be achieved through the Common Framework.
Following up on the commitments in the FfD4 Compromiso de Sevilla the UN, along with the IMF and the World Bank, has now chaired a new working group to further advance the global consensus on principles for responsible sovereign borrowing & lending, as well as better implementation and operationalization of existing principles.
Question: What is the Nordic Baltic constituency's position on advancing this important work in the coming year?
Ukraine
Given the ongoing and widespread destruction in Ukraine, the country will not be able to meet its debt servicing obligations in the future – the debt is unsustainable. However, in the new IMF program starting in February 2026, it is said that an annual debt service of 1 billion US-Dollar to non-multilateral creditors is compatible with debt sustainability (Debt sustainability under scrutiny: the blind spots in the new IMF programme for Ukraine - erlassjahr.de). This was not the case in the program before, where debt service to non-multilateral creditors was ruled out given the need to invest all available resources into making sure Ukraine can survive during the Russian aggression. The economic and fiscal situation has not changed for the better, rather to the contrary. The 1 billion US-dollar relate to an average debt service to pre-war private creditors after the two debt restructuring deals 2024 and 2025. These creditors do not provide any emergency finance during the war to support Ukraine’s defense effort, different from multilateral creditors, which are repaid, too.
Question: What is the basis for the IMF to assess this debt service as being compatible with debt sustainability?